Las salidas de custodia muestran direcciones de destino incorrectas en Blockchain.info

Estoy interesado en la siguiente transacción multisig

3a0c283c8574205c2cc95cea0e603bfff9087af2ab0360ebd2e98740a3193a18

Si consulto bitcoind para obtener información al respecto usando el siguiente comando

 $> bitcoind getrawtransaction 3a0c283c8574205c2cc95cea0e603bfff9087af2ab0360ebd2e98740a3193a18 1

entonces veo que dos direcciones están involucradas en sus salidas, a saber

1HT7xU2Ngenf7D4yocz2SAcnNLW7rK8d4E and 1GcFhAQGFZVDAr4jiR2tKwisHcgNUjhGNC.

Sin embargo, si busco este mismo hash de transacción en blockchain.info, que se encuentra aquí

https://blockchain.info/tx/3a0c283c8574205c2cc95cea0e603bfff9087af2ab0360ebd2e98740a3193a18

De repente, hay tres direcciones involucradas en las salidas, a saber

17YnWEp2vjT1wEgALyy2BApY8CAMr78M7o and 1ADwCr1Ary8KX2i41MhQKL4TgkTRV6p14G and 1GcFhAQGFZVDAr4jiR2tKwisHcgNUjhGNC.

¿Adónde fue la dirección 1HT7xU2Ngenf7D4yocz2SAcnNLW7rK8d4E y cuáles son estas dos nuevas direcciones? He notado esto para la mayoría de las transacciones multisig de blockchain.info, ¿no pueden analizarlas correctamente?

EDITAR: Aquí está el resultado que obtengo cuando ejecuto

bitcoind getrawtransaction 3a0c283c8574205c2cc95cea0e603bfff9087af2ab0360ebd2e98740a3193a18 1


{
"hex" : "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",
"txid" : "3a0c283c8574205c2cc95cea0e603bfff9087af2ab0360ebd2e98740a3193a18",
"version" : 1,
"locktime" : 0,
"vin" : [
    {
        "txid" : "be041dbcf26c03e44853b48585c4a4ffe6a29a8bf33e6fc341cca2f3a256850a",
        "vout" : 0,
        "scriptSig" : {
            "asm" : "3045022100c177dca01b7208feb04497d8948e832af7b12b5b74d1ff07db4a40c3782250b602205211a54941fe741e7220d90eda8ec75bb337b7ad7d8a9b0c40c614b2639cc37701 0336aa4df526a776e2b72512bb65d8ad5c661360cc1de2ffe460b618c0bba6641e",
            "hex" : "483045022100c177dca01b7208feb04497d8948e832af7b12b5b74d1ff07db4a40c3782250b602205211a54941fe741e7220d90eda8ec75bb337b7ad7d8a9b0c40c614b2639cc37701210336aa4df526a776e2b72512bb65d8ad5c661360cc1de2ffe460b618c0bba6641e"
        },
        "sequence" : 4294967295
    },
    {
        "txid" : "0fa11650c73cd2522c7ecf2f6d7363d26d23c25cdc02630433ab588f4063d6ea",
        "vout" : 0,
        "scriptSig" : {
            "asm" : "3045022100dc123d788fdc315f71df992a09d2f31237aadee954f0c7ed9ebf6676fde2806c022016f32f64109b92895ad35d6da1ad050fd1313e40092e51e222eed8cb9803277601 0336aa4df526a776e2b72512bb65d8ad5c661360cc1de2ffe460b618c0bba6641e",
            "hex" : "483045022100dc123d788fdc315f71df992a09d2f31237aadee954f0c7ed9ebf6676fde2806c022016f32f64109b92895ad35d6da1ad050fd1313e40092e51e222eed8cb9803277601210336aa4df526a776e2b72512bb65d8ad5c661360cc1de2ffe460b618c0bba6641e"
        },
        "sequence" : 4294967295
    },
    {
        "txid" : "0be4e71854504e99b491424826722e65d3bc369f7687ccda72b80673da7226ab",
        "vout" : 0,
        "scriptSig" : {
            "asm" : "3046022100f4eec08e55254dd3f1803c88b47bf4d0527af7b6d54d3c28300175ab2cf4cde6022100ea58b455294ca78bcca651b4031a0049c4b359834d6face1d87fe39c6ac9914e01 0336aa4df526a776e2b72512bb65d8ad5c661360cc1de2ffe460b618c0bba6641e",
            "hex" : "493046022100f4eec08e55254dd3f1803c88b47bf4d0527af7b6d54d3c28300175ab2cf4cde6022100ea58b455294ca78bcca651b4031a0049c4b359834d6face1d87fe39c6ac9914e01210336aa4df526a776e2b72512bb65d8ad5c661360cc1de2ffe460b618c0bba6641e"
        },
        "sequence" : 4294967295
    },
    {
        "txid" : "fcacf93adb64540df1b730f3c9706ac9c3c8a86d7a14ce8752eb4c1a6eb7a6d9",
        "vout" : 1,
        "scriptSig" : {
            "asm" : "3046022100ccb7797be4de4e6b890869fed98d2d66bfeb787fc3a10d9da4735688d2c1b3230221009dcff82c291fdb90ac15325a02073e52686addf8b0c25eb28dc8b410e8c3282901 0336aa4df526a776e2b72512bb65d8ad5c661360cc1de2ffe460b618c0bba6641e",
            "hex" : "493046022100ccb7797be4de4e6b890869fed98d2d66bfeb787fc3a10d9da4735688d2c1b3230221009dcff82c291fdb90ac15325a02073e52686addf8b0c25eb28dc8b410e8c3282901210336aa4df526a776e2b72512bb65d8ad5c661360cc1de2ffe460b618c0bba6641e"
        },
        "sequence" : 4294967295
    }
],
"vout" : [
    {
        "value" : 0.00007800,
        "n" : 0,
        "scriptPubKey" : {
            "asm" : "1 0336aa4df526a776e2b72512bb65d8ad5c661360cc1de2ffe460b618c0bba6641e 20434e5452505254590000000a00000000d806c1d5000000039dc87f4000000000 2 OP_CHECKMULTISIG",
            "hex" : "51210336aa4df526a776e2b72512bb65d8ad5c661360cc1de2ffe460b618c0bba6641e2120434e5452505254590000000a00000000d806c1d5000000039dc87f400000000052ae",
            "reqSigs" : 1,
            "type" : "multisig",
            "addresses" : [
                "1GcFhAQGFZVDAr4jiR2tKwisHcgNUjhGNC",
                "1HT7xU2Ngenf7D4yocz2SAcnNLW7rK8d4E"
            ]
        }
    },
    {
        "value" : 0.00007800,
        "n" : 1,
        "scriptPubKey" : {
            "asm" : "1 0336aa4df526a776e2b72512bb65d8ad5c661360cc1de2ffe460b618c0bba6641e 1600000001000000005f5e100003e8000000000000000000000000000000000000 2 OP_CHECKMULTISIG",
            "hex" : "51210336aa4df526a776e2b72512bb65d8ad5c661360cc1de2ffe460b618c0bba6641e211600000001000000005f5e100003e800000000000000000000000000000000000052ae",
            "reqSigs" : 1,
            "type" : "multisig",
            "addresses" : [
                "1GcFhAQGFZVDAr4jiR2tKwisHcgNUjhGNC",
                "1HT7xU2Ngenf7D4yocz2SAcnNLW7rK8d4E"
            ]
        }
    },
    {
        "value" : 0.00732450,
        "n" : 2,
        "scriptPubKey" : {
            "asm" : "OP_DUP OP_HASH160 ab34b5c668a8ed435ede840b6f40e3eddb455c62 OP_EQUALVERIFY OP_CHECKSIG",
            "hex" : "76a914ab34b5c668a8ed435ede840b6f40e3eddb455c6288ac",
            "reqSigs" : 1,
            "type" : "pubkeyhash",
            "addresses" : [
                "1GcFhAQGFZVDAr4jiR2tKwisHcgNUjhGNC"
            ]
        }
    }
],
"blockhash" : "000000000000000010fd711cae1e3069a90e657664872ff019f3544fe78f9284",
"confirmations" : 1166,
"time" : 1404255586,
"blocktime" : 1404255586

}

Respuestas (2)

Veamos detenidamente https://blockchain.info/tx/3a0c283c8574205c2cc95cea0e603bfff9087af2ab0360ebd2e98740a3193a18

la salida n.° 0 es msig 1 de 2 a { 0336aa4df526a776e2b72512bb65d8ad5c661360cc1de2ffe460b618c0bba6641e, 20434e5452505254590000000a00000000d806c1d50000c00039040

el primer número largo [0336..641e] es la clave pública de la dirección 1GcFhAQGFZVDAr4jiR2tKwisHcgNUjhGNC

el segundo [2043..0000] no es una dirección pública en absoluto. bc.i lo convierte en una dirección 17YnWEp2vjT1wEgALyy2BApY8CAMr78M7o

la dirección 1HT7xU2Ngenf7D4yocz2SAcnNLW7rK8d4E es hash160 (0000...0000) - clave pública no válida

me parece que el cliente convierte todas las claves públicas no válidas para abordar 1HT7xU2Ngenf7D4yocz2SAcnNLW7rK8d4E

mira aquí: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=8728.msg202068#msg202068

y aquí: http://code.google.com/p/bitcoinj/issues/detail?id=264

Ah, es bueno saberlo, gracias por señalarlo. Me sorprende que no hayan arreglado eso para devolver algún valor centinela que llame la atención sobre el hecho de que están usando una dirección no válida.

En primer lugar, hubiera sido más fácil si pegaras el bitcoind getrawtransactionresultado, que es el siguiente:

{
"hex" : "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",
"txid" : "3a0c283c8574205c2cc95cea0e603bfff9087af2ab0360ebd2e98740a3193a18",
"version" : 1,
"locktime" : 0,
"vin" : [
    {
        "txid" : "be041dbcf26c03e44853b48585c4a4ffe6a29a8bf33e6fc341cca2f3a256850a",
        "vout" : 0,
        "scriptSig" : {
            "asm" : "3045022100c177dca01b7208feb04497d8948e832af7b12b5b74d1ff07db4a40c3782250b602205211a54941fe741e7220d90eda8ec75bb337b7ad7d8a9b0c40c614b2639cc37701 0336aa4df526a776e2b72512bb65d8ad5c661360cc1de2ffe460b618c0bba6641e",
            "hex" : "483045022100c177dca01b7208feb04497d8948e832af7b12b5b74d1ff07db4a40c3782250b602205211a54941fe741e7220d90eda8ec75bb337b7ad7d8a9b0c40c614b2639cc37701210336aa4df526a776e2b72512bb65d8ad5c661360cc1de2ffe460b618c0bba6641e"
        },
        "sequence" : 4294967295
    },
    {
        "txid" : "0fa11650c73cd2522c7ecf2f6d7363d26d23c25cdc02630433ab588f4063d6ea",
        "vout" : 0,
        "scriptSig" : {
            "asm" : "3045022100dc123d788fdc315f71df992a09d2f31237aadee954f0c7ed9ebf6676fde2806c022016f32f64109b92895ad35d6da1ad050fd1313e40092e51e222eed8cb9803277601 0336aa4df526a776e2b72512bb65d8ad5c661360cc1de2ffe460b618c0bba6641e",
            "hex" : "483045022100dc123d788fdc315f71df992a09d2f31237aadee954f0c7ed9ebf6676fde2806c022016f32f64109b92895ad35d6da1ad050fd1313e40092e51e222eed8cb9803277601210336aa4df526a776e2b72512bb65d8ad5c661360cc1de2ffe460b618c0bba6641e"
        },
        "sequence" : 4294967295
    },
    {
        "txid" : "0be4e71854504e99b491424826722e65d3bc369f7687ccda72b80673da7226ab",
        "vout" : 0,
        "scriptSig" : {
            "asm" : "3046022100f4eec08e55254dd3f1803c88b47bf4d0527af7b6d54d3c28300175ab2cf4cde6022100ea58b455294ca78bcca651b4031a0049c4b359834d6face1d87fe39c6ac9914e01 0336aa4df526a776e2b72512bb65d8ad5c661360cc1de2ffe460b618c0bba6641e",
            "hex" : "493046022100f4eec08e55254dd3f1803c88b47bf4d0527af7b6d54d3c28300175ab2cf4cde6022100ea58b455294ca78bcca651b4031a0049c4b359834d6face1d87fe39c6ac9914e01210336aa4df526a776e2b72512bb65d8ad5c661360cc1de2ffe460b618c0bba6641e"
        },
        "sequence" : 4294967295
    },
    {
        "txid" : "fcacf93adb64540df1b730f3c9706ac9c3c8a86d7a14ce8752eb4c1a6eb7a6d9",
        "vout" : 1,
        "scriptSig" : {
            "asm" : "3046022100ccb7797be4de4e6b890869fed98d2d66bfeb787fc3a10d9da4735688d2c1b3230221009dcff82c291fdb90ac15325a02073e52686addf8b0c25eb28dc8b410e8c3282901 0336aa4df526a776e2b72512bb65d8ad5c661360cc1de2ffe460b618c0bba6641e",
            "hex" : "493046022100ccb7797be4de4e6b890869fed98d2d66bfeb787fc3a10d9da4735688d2c1b3230221009dcff82c291fdb90ac15325a02073e52686addf8b0c25eb28dc8b410e8c3282901210336aa4df526a776e2b72512bb65d8ad5c661360cc1de2ffe460b618c0bba6641e"
        },
        "sequence" : 4294967295
    }
],
"vout" : [
    {
        "value" : 0.00007800,
        "n" : 0,
        "scriptPubKey" : {
            "asm" : "1 0336aa4df526a776e2b72512bb65d8ad5c661360cc1de2ffe460b618c0bba6641e 20434e5452505254590000000a00000000d806c1d5000000039dc87f4000000000 2 OP_CHECKMULTISIG",
            "hex" : "51210336aa4df526a776e2b72512bb65d8ad5c661360cc1de2ffe460b618c0bba6641e2120434e5452505254590000000a00000000d806c1d5000000039dc87f400000000052ae",
            "reqSigs" : 1,
            "type" : "multisig",
            "addresses" : [
                "1GcFhAQGFZVDAr4jiR2tKwisHcgNUjhGNC",
                "17YnWEp2vjT1wEgALyy2BApY8CAMr78M7o"
            ]
        }
    },
    {
        "value" : 0.00007800,
        "n" : 1,
        "scriptPubKey" : {
            "asm" : "1 0336aa4df526a776e2b72512bb65d8ad5c661360cc1de2ffe460b618c0bba6641e 1600000001000000005f5e100003e8000000000000000000000000000000000000 2 OP_CHECKMULTISIG",
            "hex" : "51210336aa4df526a776e2b72512bb65d8ad5c661360cc1de2ffe460b618c0bba6641e211600000001000000005f5e100003e800000000000000000000000000000000000052ae",
            "reqSigs" : 1,
            "type" : "multisig",
            "addresses" : [
                "1GcFhAQGFZVDAr4jiR2tKwisHcgNUjhGNC",
                "1ADwCr1Ary8KX2i41MhQKL4TgkTRV6p14G"
            ]
        }
    },
    {
        "value" : 0.00732450,
        "n" : 2,
        "scriptPubKey" : {
            "asm" : "OP_DUP OP_HASH160 ab34b5c668a8ed435ede840b6f40e3eddb455c62 OP_EQUALVERIFY OP_CHECKSIG",
            "hex" : "76a914ab34b5c668a8ed435ede840b6f40e3eddb455c6288ac",
            "reqSigs" : 1,
            "type" : "pubkeyhash",
            "addresses" : [
                "1GcFhAQGFZVDAr4jiR2tKwisHcgNUjhGNC"
            ]
        }
    }
],
"blockhash" : "000000000000000010fd711cae1e3069a90e657664872ff019f3544fe78f9284",
"confirmations" : 1100,
"time" : 1404255586,
"blocktime" : 1404255586

}

En la salida anterior hay tres salidas que parecen estar de acuerdo con blockchain.info. Biteasy.com también reporta el mismo resultado .

¿Estás seguro de que estás ejecutando el último bitcoind?

esto es alarmante Edité mi publicación original para incluir mi salida. ¿Qué versión de bitcoind estás ejecutando? Al ejecutar el comando RPC "getinfo", veo que estoy ejecutando la versión 90100, con la versión de protocolo 70002.
Hm, estoy ejecutando una versión anterior a la tuya en la máquina. Probé esto. Volveré a comprobar en un bitcoind más reciente.
Las salidas de custodia muestran direcciones de destino incorrectas en Blockchain.info
RespuestasAquíPolítica de privacidad1y, 1v